When Guilt Is Running Your To-Do List

You look up one day and realize you've slid back into the pattern. The one you thought you'd dealt with. The over-promising, the over-extending, the saying yes when every part of you knows the answer should be no. And your first thought is: what is wrong with me?

Nothing is wrong with you. But something is probably driving those behaviors, and my guess is it rhymes with "tilt."

I had a coaching session recently that really brought this home for me. My client had experienced the death of a patient. Unexpected, post-surgical, nothing she had missed. And in the days that followed, she found herself pouring hours into consoling the patient's spouse, and building out this extensive list of promises she'd made to other patients. Looking up specialists in cities she didn't practice in. Agreeing to review charts for patients who weren't even hers.

When we pulled back the curtain on all of it, the driver was guilt.

Guilt doesn't sit still

Here's what I want you to understand about guilt: it doesn't just make you feel bad. It makes you do things. It generates action, often action that looks a lot like care and compassion from the outside, but that is actually coming from a place of "I must fix this, I must make it right, I must do more."

Brené Brown distinguishes guilt and shame in a way I find really clarifying: guilt is "I did something wrong," and shame is "I am something wrong." For physicians, those two things got collapsed somewhere in training. A bad outcome on rounds. A patient question you couldn't answer. A history that didn't match in front of the attending. The message, intended or not, was: something went wrong, and you are the reason.

That wiring doesn't just disappear when you leave residency.

The part nobody's talking about

There's a newer layer to this that I think we need to be honest about. Patients are making significant health decisions without us. GLPs from online pharmacies. Compounded peptides. Protocols from wellness influencers. And when something goes sideways, we feel the weight of it even when we had absolutely no knowledge it was happening.

I had a patient who came in recently with side effects from a medication she hadn't told me she was taking. My first reaction was that sinking feeling of having missed something. But when I stepped back: I had no idea. I couldn't have known. That is not a failure of mine to own.

We are consultants. We bring our expertise, our knowledge, our honest clinical judgment. What our patients choose to do with that, and what they choose to do on their own, is not something we can control or be responsible for. Holding ourselves accountable for the unknowable is not conscientiousness. It's a path toward burning out completely.

What to do when you notice the pattern

If you've looked at your behavior lately and thought "I thought I was past this," I want to offer you some grace. When we are carrying heavy emotions, especially ones we haven't fully processed, old behaviors tend to come back. That is not evidence of failure. It's information.

The question to get curious about is: what is this behavior trying to manage? What emotion is running the show right now? Because when you can name it, you can start to work with it instead of just reacting to it.

You deserve support in doing that work. Not because something is wrong with you. Because the work you do is genuinely hard, and you shouldn't have to navigate it alone.

If you want more content like this delivered directly to your inbox, come join the community at healthierforgood.com. I write for women physicians every week, and I'd love for you to be part of the conversation.